With six African countries in the top ten fastest-growing economies in the world and the continent being demographically the youngest, the 1.2 billion people living in this continent are gradually becoming positioned for the financial revolution of DeFi. Traditional banking systems in Africa have recently seen being on the verge of default due to debt and currency crisis, making the population wanting better access to banking solutions and customer services.
With decreasing trust in traditional banking institutions, the young and tech-savvy population are in need of digital solutions to problems of accessing banking and controlling their own finances, such as through a Decentralized Financing (DeFi) model. With DeFi, people in Africa without adequate access to banking can finally gain access to financial tools such as being provided liquidity, borrowing, lending, (insure), saving, etc, that will be essential in a growing economic market. It is important to discuss how DeFi will leapfrog traditional banking in Africa as it will be able to provide access to banking to a larger population that traditional banks were not capable of doing so.
How DeFi can help to defeat illicit transactions in the traditional banking system
The growth of the African economy has been stalled by intransparency. The emerging markets in the continent are controlled by a few people who want to maintain a monopolistic market. The traditional banking system has been known to be susceptible to mutability, and alterations, a fundamental flaw leverageable when engaging in under-the-table transactions, money-laundering, diverting funds or defrauding investors.
This centralized and opaque system makes it easier for concealing illicit transactions, aiding bad actors with the necessary platform for looting funds to the United States and Europe. With DeFi, every user can monitor the movement of money from the economy through the system; because DeFi is an open network, users can monitor the movement of illegal funds.
Traditional banks require the government’s approval to operate, which makes it easier for them to be influenced by the government, a level of dependency that easily makes them pawns. With DeFi, a lot of problems are addressed because anyone would be able to create their digital bank, which is accessible in Africa.
How DeFi can help to solve the banking crisis in Africa
The popularity of mobile banking in Africa has increased in recent years because of the arrival of cheap smartphone brands like Infinix and Techno. Most people in rural communities cannot afford expensive smartphones like the iPhone. There were more than 500 million internet users in Africa by December 2019, which means most African communities are connected to the internet.
The rise of mobile banking and USSD have increased recently. Many fintech companies like Paystack, Opay, and Flutterwave have come out with solutions that can improve transactions’ speed. The speed of transaction is essential for the growth of Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) and is also essential for the growth of the economy. Many businesses in Nigeria prefer to collect large payments through bank transfers or cards to protect themselves from theft.
TechCrunch reported that Flutterwave processed 107 million transactions worth US$ 5 billion. The companies working on these solutions still have to work under the central authority to achieve their aims. Their operation rules are mostly dictated by the government’s central bank, unlike DeFi, which has no central authority.
Zimbabwe as a case study
Zimbabwe is one of the greatest examples of the banking crisis that has been experienced by a country in Africa. The economy crashed, and the country’s central bank looked for a temporary solution to their problem, which is printing money, which escalated the crisis because as the money printing increased, the Zimbabwe dollar devalued to the extent that trillions of their currency couldn’t purchase bread in the market.
The citizens abandoned the currency, and banks were forced to adopt the Chinese yuan or US dollar as a means of payment for local transactions. The banks issued banknotes not because it was demanded by the public who had already lost faith in it, but because they were instructed by the central government to do so.
The adoption of DeFi in Africa will provide individuals necessary freedom, and tools to help manage their personal finances, with less government restriction encountered. Hedge against inflation and the decentralized system means that you can decide what to do with your money, unlike the central banks, which dictate how your money should be spent.
Nigeria as a case study
There is an ongoing banking crisis in Nigeria. It is less discussed because it hasn’t led to hyperinflation like in Zimbabwe, but we do not know the extent of this current banking crisis. The Central Bank of Nigeria pegged the Naira’s value to around ₦387, but the problem is that there is a wide shortage of dollars, and people are forced to buy dollars from the local exchange market that pegs it at ₦480.
This development has affected and stalled foreign investment in the country, and banks can no longer sell dollars to the public. Many Nigerians are now using blockchain solutions like Bitcoin and Etherum for foreign transactions. Still, it would be preferable for them to adopt a decentralized financial system for their transactions with a proper currency structure. DeFi can provide a better currency infrastructure in which businesses can have access to foreign exchange without government restrictions.
How DeFi can help in the flexibility of loans
Access to loans is one of the most important parts of the economy, loans are important for businesses to grow, and businesses’ growth will help grow countries’ economies. Banks are responsible for giving out loans in Africa, but the problem is that many banks prefer to earn through transfer charges and substantial amounts of money is deducted from their clients than making interest from loans.
Many central banks do not have a proper structure for lending, banks are also afraid to take risks with loans, so they set up collateral rules that are almost impossible to meet by small businesses. They can ask for a property worth 5 million for you to obtain a loan of 1 million, which is unrealistic. Many banks in Africa are also afraid of being defrauded.
Another challenge with traditional loans is where banks and business owners take advantage of the system. This situation happened in Nigeria, where banks were lending loans to borrowers without collateral. The fraud occurred because the banks received bribes from the businessmen that enabled them to get collateral-free loans, which they did not payback. An EFCC (Nigeria government organization responsible for fighting fraud) spokesman, Femi Babafemi, told local media,
“With the collaboration of both the debtors and the bankers, they have been using fictitious companies and names to apply for loans and get at this money. That also raises the question of money laundering.”
DeFi can solve loan problems in Africa. We have the possibility of creating a decentralized loan system like AAVE or dYdX in which the participants will provide liquidity to earn a profit on interest, and businesses can lend loans to grow. UTU is a company in Kenya that is testing out uncollateralized loans with DeFi.
The African economy is undergoing tremendous growth that has not been experienced before. Opportunities offered in terms of transparency are extremely valuable to counter banks supported by untrustworthy governments, which contribute to illicit trades and money laundering, overall not fulfilling their duties towards economic development.
If the people in Africa, especially with it being the youngest continent in the world, can adopt DeFi, this would lead to a massive increase in banking access for millions of people. This helps them to control their finances, enabling businesses to grow by accessing quick loans. This also includes expanding banking service to rural regions, where mobile payment may be more accessible than traditional banking systems, that could potentially alleviate some factors of inequality between rural and urban areas.
However, it is also important to mention the limitation of Defi in bringing access to finance in the African continent, especially in terms of a lack of concrete governance in emerging economies without a developed financial infrastructure that could result in transparency being an issue. DeFi application is limited to who is using them, and if a corrupt institution uses DeFi technology, they may be able to continue their corrupt behaviours through this technology. This is especially the case in emerging economies, like many in the African continent, that still have a loose legal structure that may not be able to govern fraudulent activities on the DeFi network as of yet.
Aly Madhavji is the Managing Partner at Blockchain Founders Fund which invests in and venture builds top-tier Start-ups and consults organizations such as the UN. He is a LP at Loyal VC and Draper Goren Holm, an award-winning author, a Senior Blockchain Fellow at INSEAD, and recognized as a “Blockchain 100” Global Leader by Lattice80.
Mario Egie is the CEO of Kite Financial. Mario has a first degree in physics and has been working as a software developer for more than 4 years. He is the winner of the Tony Elumelu–U.S. Consulate entrepreneurship award of 2019. With a keen interest in African capitalism, Mario founded Kite Financial — a Nigerian blockchain-cryptocurrency startup that is ushering a new financial infrastructure, which will provide the youthful continent financial access, inclusion and freedom.
CBN vs Cryptocurrency; the gold rush, time for a change?
Despite the CBN’s concern about Cryptocurrency in Nigeria, the cryptocurrency space has continued to roll out ingenious solutions to real-world problems.
Despite the Central Bank of Nigeria expressing its concern about Cryptocurrency in Nigeria, the cryptocurrency space has continued to roll out ingenious solutions to real-world problems. One of the most recent solutions is the advent of Non-Fungible Tokens (NFTs), a unit of data stored on a blockchain to certify that a digital asset is unique and non-interchangeable. It is an innovation that allows that an artist gets digitized title/ownership for their work.
Based on a report from Coinbase yesterday, NFTs’ adoption is fast growing among Nigerian creatives, given that it provides a marketplace for creatives and art collectors across the globe. Although currently, the platform has recorded complaints from some artists whose artworks were minted without their consent, the platform’s potential market for African creatives is undeniably massive.
Over time, the Nigerian creative industry has been quiet due to perennial problems such as inadequacy of patronage and piracy, which disincentivizes players in the space. This problem, coupled with the apparent low interest in other economic segments, led to Nigeria’s current overdependence on oil receipt. Most creative deals in the Nigerian NFT space are currently being consummated anonymously.
Furthermore, Nigeria being the second largest market for cryptocurrencies globally over the last five years, with a market worth of trade totalling 60,215BTC, portends an interesting figure when the segments’ potential proceeds are considered.
According to the National Bureau of Statistics, Nigeria has an unemployment rate of 33.3% as of Q4 2020. There is also the recent prohibition of local banks from facilitating cryptocurrency transactions. As an offshoot, the NFT’s ability to provide support to the economy in the area of rightly engaging creatives and other providers of ancillary services in the segment could be frustrated.
There are also indications that Nigeria might be setting itself up to miss out on an otherwise potent foreign exchange source. In an era where oil receipt is becoming increasingly unreliable, avenues like this could provide a decent level of support given Nigerians’ tenacity and creativity, hence drawing more accretion to its external reserves.
It is undeniable that Cryptocurrency poses some downside concerns in how it could easily aid some undesirable ventures, such as money laundering and terrorism financing. Nonetheless, we noted that Authority’s efforts should be geared more towards finding common ground where those concerns could be mitigated instead of shutting down the entire space.
Noteworthy is that the buying and selling of cryptocurrencies have continued unabated since the last CBN’s directives were issued. Is it time to retract those directives and find a more effective way of combatting cryptocurrency concerns? Yes! However, we opine that as we advance, every move should be tailored to ensure Nigeria is not blindsided in this gold rush.
CSL Stockbrokers Limited, Lagos (CSLS) is a wholly-owned subsidiary of FCMB Group Plc and is regulated by the Securities and Exchange Commission, Nigeria. CSLS is a member of the Nigerian Stock Exchange.
SEC and the proliferation of unregistered investment platforms
The recent move has generated diverse views from stakeholders with some critics classifying this action as irrational.
According to a circular issued by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), it affirmed its knowledge of the existence of trading platforms that allow investors access to securities listed in other jurisdictions.
The capital market regulator further reiterated the provisions of sections 67-70 of the Investments and Securities Act (ISA), 2007 and Rules 414 & 415 of the SEC Rules and Regulations which state that only foreign securities listed on any exchange registered in Nigeria may be issued, sold or offered for sale or subscription through approved channels to the Nigerian public.
The announcement furthers SEC’s quest to strengthen investor protection, promote transparency in the operations of the Nigerian capital market and ensure all investment transactions are within the regulatory purview of the commission.
Recently, the capital market regulator introduced a new requirement for the inclusion of the commission’s contact details in all prospectuses or offer documents issued to the general public in a bid to ascertain the genuineness of such securities. Besides, it is often found that the activities of illegal fund managers become prevalent during a financial or economic downturn, making the public susceptible to the juicy yet unsustainable returns promised by these managers.
The recent move has generated diverse views from stakeholders with some critics classifying this action as irrational. They cited the impact of investing in foreign stocks on portfolio diversification and the role of Fintechs in driving financial inclusion among others. On the other hand, supporters of this action argued for the need to reduce the pressure on external reserves especially at a time when the green-back is needed to stimulate economic recovery.
Also, that it helps to safeguard the country’s investing community. We recall that the recent policy by the CBN to close all accounts by Deposit Money Banks (DMBs) and Other Financial Institutions (OFIs) involved in dealing with cryptocurrencies received a lot of backlash from the public.
On this move, however, we opine that it is still within the legal purview of the SEC to discourage investments in foreign listed securities. Nonetheless, we are aware of the concept of globalization in commerce and thus, there might be a need for a rejig of the Investment and Securities Act 2007, and other related acts to capture current trends and developments in the investment globe.
To avoid backlash going forward, we suggest more public education for clarity with regards to future policy decisions.
CSL Stockbrokers Limited, Lagos (CSLS) is a wholly owned subsidiary of FCMB Group Plc and is regulated by the Securities and Exchange Commission, Nigeria. CSLS is a member of the Nigerian Stock Exchange.
Nairametrics | Company Earnings
Access our Live Feed portal for the latest company earnings as they drop.
- Nigerian Breweries publishes names of over 100,000 shareholders who are yet to claim their dividends.
- 2020 FY Results: Sovereign Trust Insurance Plc records a 37% increase in profit after tax.
- CSCS Plc posts profit after tax of N6.93 billion in FY 2020
- BUA Cement Plc announces Board Meeting
- Infinity Trust Mortgage Bank Plc records a 60% increase in profit after tax in Q1 2021.