Connect with us
nairametrics

Business News

Mobile money war: Telecoms threaten banks’ future in Nigeria

Mobile money war: The future of commercial banks is gradually slipping into the hands of telecommunication companies.

Published

on

Advertising, Nigerian banks' expenses on advertising

The future of commercial banks is gradually slipping into the hands of telecommunication companies, and this doesn’t bode well for the Nigerian lenders, as the inroad into mobile money market by network providers is likely to make banks redundant soon. 

Before the entrance of the GSM firms in Nigeria’s telecommunication industry in 2001, having a mobile phone and getting across to people within seconds, no matter how far they were, was something akin to a miracle. They had made the seemingly impossible to become easy. But no matter how much of a feat it had accomplished, no one expected it to grow into an industry capable of making financial payments. Drawing a correlation between network providers and bank functions was far-fetched, but fast track to 2019, and they are now officially recognized as operators of payment service bank (PSB). 

Mobile money is the payment of services or financial transaction between a buyer and merchant through mobile phone. The payment system is also called mobile payment and mobile wallet. Individuals can buy goods and pay for services through the use of USSD code or mobile app.

The quest to bring banking closer to the under-served for financial inclusion has accelerated the value of telecoms firms. The idea of allowing telcos to operate as mobile money service providers had been frowned at in the past, but all that is changing, as Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) has come to realize that achieving its 80% financial inclusion is impossible without the likes of MTN Nigeria, Airtel, Glo and other telecoms firms.

READ ALSO: Nigerian Eurobonds Dip Following Less Dovish US FED Stance

GTBank 728 x 90

Banks sentiment 

A handful of bank Chief Executive Officers (CEOs) have talked tough regarding the readiness of commercial banks for the inclusion of telecoms in the mobile money market, however, putting the lenders and telcos side by side, it’s evident that the CEOs will be singing a different tune when this becomes fully operational.

FIRS demands tax payment from MTN Nigeria

MTN building.

The likes of Ifie Sekibo, Managing Director and CEO of Heritage Bank, Nnamdi Okonkwo, MD/CEO, Fidelity Bank, and some others have all stated that the presence of telecoms in the mobile money service brews no fear. 

GTBank 728 x 90

Such is expected, as market rivals are known to never speak of themselves as inferior to competitors; but if statistics are anything to go by and with comparison to other market in Africa where mobile money is thriving, banks are gradually heading towards that “inferior” direction if the threat posed by telcos is not handled properly. 

Numbers are against banks 

It would be unwise to bet against telecoms firms in the mobile money market, considering the position they hold and number of subscribers they each possess. While banks had only until recently began to drive traction to their mobile payment platforms, network providers have been building their customer base since their entry into the Nigerian market. 

In the telecoms sector, all network providers account for over 122.2 million subscribers, with interested mobile money operators such as MTN Nigeria and Airtel Africa accounting for 52.2 million and 31.9 million respectively. This is more than the number of customers in GTBank, Zenith Bank, Access Bank, UBA and other banks. The total number of active bank accounts is 72.9 million. 

The subscriber number of Airtel Nigeria is more than the number of app downloads of these banks put together. And when you add MTN, Glo and 9mobile to the list, the chances of the lenders acquiring sizeable market share in the mobile money market become slimmer. 

GTBank, Zenith Bank, Access Bank all have about 1 million downloads, but note that not all downloaders make use of these apps, and having multiple apps for each bank account is stressful, so telcos provide a seamless payment system that doesn’t require multiple accounts or cards. 

Jaiz bank ads

READ MORE: CBN warns MfBs against hoarding as lenders begin to disburse N100, other lower notes 

Fidelity ads

While these banks have tried to simplify their transaction processes with USSD codes, the codes are not as popular as the network provider’s USSD among Nigerians. 

History favours Telcos 

The inclusion of telecoms as payment service banks by CBN was encouraged by the rate of financial inclusion success in Kenya. The country’s financial inclusion is pegged at 95%, and this is because of MPesa, Africa’s first mobile money platform. 

MPesa was created by telecoms firm, Safaricom, to close the gap between the under-served and financial transactions. When Saraficom’s mobile money began, there were 3000 ATMs (Automated Teller Machines), but the volume dropped by 1000 because Kenyans no longer visited banking halls to make payments. 

The expansion of Kenyan banks also slowed in response to bank customers’ behavioural changes regarding transactions. Also, account opening dropped, since Kenyans began to prefer using mobile phones to send, receive and store money. But in order not to be devoured by the onslaught of telecoms-sponsored MPesa, the banks in Kenyan drafted an initiative to partner MPesa to stay afloat; that move has paid off well. 

Divide and conquer 

Since the function of banks is not limited to payment or financial transactions, one might think the bank’s relevance is still vital enough to be significant to Nigerians, however, the responsibility of providing loans to customers to help inject capital in the business is not restricted to Nigerian banks only. 

The functions of banks have been split over the years. While network providers only recently received the nod to operate mobile money without loan service, Fintech companies and Venture Capitalists have been offering needed capital to Nigerian businesses especially start ups and have become perfect substitutes of banks for monetary needs; even rating agency, Moody, has argued that commercial banks might soon lose their services to Fintech firms due to their growing popularity.

This division of bank duties has reduced the essence of banks in Nigeria. Their monopoly over payment and monetary transactions has been lessened, and already, the inclination of the middle-class and lower-class towards them regarding loans isn’t favourable. 

Coronation ads

In the report of FUGAZ for the year ended 2018, the companies loan to customers dropped except for UBA. GTBank recorded N1.2 trillion in 2018 compared to the N1.4 trillion of 2017. Access Bank also recorded N1.993 trillion in 2018 from the previous year’s N1.995 trillion. Zenith dropped from N1.9 billion to N1.7 billion in 2018. While this drop in some quarters could be attributed to banks cutting back loans given, it could also be argued that Nigerians are reducing their dependence on banks. 

With this division of bank duties, the future of banks is on a cliff edge, and operation in banking halls will be rocked to its foundation, which might result in job loss. The 4th industrial revolution has stretched the banking sector so far that lack of innovation by Bankers Association of Nigeria might leave the traditional financial market counting their losses. 

app
Airtel Africa listing on NSE, MTN Nigeria listing on NSE

Airtel building.

Lessons from Kenya 

Some banks are calling for the CBN to impose regulatory conditions on telecoms interested in mobile money operation, in order to curb its growth. This shows how fearful they are getting, but now is not the time to make requests that will result in unfriendly competition and rule out collaboration, because that’s the saving grace available to banks. 

It should be noted that lenders in Kenya initially went on the offensive against network operators, but as time went by, more Kenyans ported to telcos mobile money service. To put an end to this migration, Kenyan Bankers Association liaised with Safaricom’s MPesa to create M-Shwari to offer loans to mobile money users; this stopped what could have become a banking crisis in Kenya. 

Conclusion 

Banks can’t operate alone in the 4th industrial revolution era, they need to pitch tents with the telecoms companies, rather than compete against them if they are to survive the crisis lurking around to consume them.  

The longevity of banks in Nigeria now depends on how banks handle the competition from telecoms and how innovative the financial players are, as they need to do more than create apps or USSD codes to sway or maintain customers. 

Olalekan is a certified media practitioner from the Nigerian Institute of Journalism (NIJ). In the era of media convergence, Olalekan is a valuable asset, with ability to curate and broadcast news. His zeal to write was developed out of passion to shape people’s thought and opinion; serving as a guideline for their daily lives. Contact for tips: [email protected]

4 Comments

4 Comments

  1. Abdul Bamgbopa

    August 21, 2019 at 12:47 pm

    very well put together piece and already useful as Secondary research source. Kudos

    • Fakoyejo Olalekan

      November 28, 2019 at 9:11 am

      Thanks Abdul

  2. David

    August 21, 2019 at 6:08 pm

    Bank CEO’S need to read this 🤔👍

    • Fakoyejo Olalekan

      November 28, 2019 at 9:12 am

      Lol… Yes, I think they do.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

ENDSARS

#EndSARS: Protests may return if panels do not address all issues in 2 weeks – Former Nigerian Minister

Akinyemi says the #EndSARS protesters would return to the streets if their demands are not addressed in two weeks.

Published

on

This was disclosed by Professor Bolaji Akinyemi, during a news interview with ARISE TV this afternoon, as he called on the FG to urgently address the issues raised by the protesters, as these issues extend beyond police brutality and the immediate reform of the Nigeria Police force.
He explained during the interview that the current demands of the youths extend beyond basic needs, which remain the core mandate of the present administration.
He likened the #EndSARS protest to the #BlackLivesMatter demonstration and reiterated that demands of the youth extend beyond stomach infrastructure, as it is more of a call for good governance in a bid to address the concrete issues that the country faces.
He called for strategic actions towards combatting the evils of unemployment in Nigeria; called on the military to employ more military men to soak up the unemployment, and also provide security for the country.
On the issue of restructuring, Professor Akinyemi said restructuring is also key to solving the many problems facing the country.
The Professor of Political Science noted that the way forward for Nigeria will be for the government to utilize the Justice Mohammed Uwais report on electoral reforms and the 2014 National Conference report, which he believes addresses the issues confronting Nigerians.
What they are saying
During the interview, Professor Akinyemi said, “I will say and let me believe I am wrong, the judicial panels have just two weeks to address all these issues before the youths come back to the streets. The government should at least give the youths the impression that you have not set up all these panels to buy time, but that you are genuinely and seriously interested in addressing their issues.”
He reiterated the need for the employment of more police officers,
We told the government, because I was part of that conference, that the United Nations said Nigeria needs 1.5 million policemen. We have only about 350,000 and we were recommending that the Nigerian government should employ 750,000 more policemen.”
What we’ve seen in the past two weeks is that we don’t have enough men in uniform to guarantee security in this country if every part of the country decides to blow up. So you serve two purposes – employment and security, and those are things you can do immediately.
“We have just seen how every Governor was scrambling around in the past two weeks; if you allow each state to have its own state police, you wouldn’t have that experience. I have heard of a situation where the streets took over even governance in almost every state. So, restructuring is that you allow things to be done at the local level.”

Continue Reading

Coronavirus

COVID-19: Jason Njoku and wife test positive

iROKOtv CEO and wife have contracted the novel coronavirus.

Published

on

Jason Njoku and Wife testes positive to Covid-19

Jason Chukwuma Njoku, the co-founder and CEO of iROKOtv and his wife has tested positive for COVID-19. However, Mrs. Mary Njoku is feeling well.

Jason,  disclosed this via his Twitter handle stating that “My enemies are hard at work in 2020. Mrs. Njoku and I tested positive for Covid-19. I’m not feeling great, but Mary is well. Literally no idea how I caught it. But we shall see this pass too.”

The media mogul did not reveal if his children caught the virus too.

GTBank 728 x 90
Continue Reading

Business

UK High Commission reopens visa application centres in Nigeria

Days after it was shut down, United Kingdom High Commission in Nigeria has announced the reopening of its visa application centres.

Published

on

#EndSARS: We are monitoring developments in Nigeria closely - UK, UK High Commission in Nigeria to replace expired visa for free, as it restarts operations

The United Kingdom High Commission in Nigeria has announced the reopening of its visa application centres in the country.

This comes some days after the high commission had shut down its visa application centres in Victoria Island, Lagos and Abuja over the outbreak of violence arising from hijacked #EndSARS protests against police brutality and extra-judicial killings, which led to the loss of lives, vandalization, and looting of public and private assets across the country.

READ: Reps, NIDO, Ghana government respond to attack on Nigerian residential building

The disclosure was made by the High Commission in a statement through a tweet post on its official Twitter handle.

The High Commission, however, noted in its statement, titled, “Update on UK visa application centres in Nigeria” that its centres would not open on Thursday due to the public holiday in Nigeria, in honour of the Eid-El Malaud celebration.

GTBank 728 x 90

The statement from the UK high commission, partly reads, “Our TLS contact visa application centres are now open in Nigeria. Following the recent closures, we are working hard to process all outstanding applications.’’

READ: NCC sets up committee to review licensing framework of Infrastructure Companies

“We thank you for your continued patience and understanding. Please note Thursday, October 29, is a public holiday in Nigeria and our Visa application centres will be closed.

GTBank 728 x 90

The reopening of the visa applications centres after they were shut about a week ago is due to the gradual return of peace and order to some of those trouble spots, following the intervention of security agents.

The UK High Commission had been very critical of the outbreak of violence in the country, especially the shooting of unarmed protesters at Lekki Tollgate by alleged military personnel, and asked the government to thoroughly investigate the incident and ensure justice is done.

READ: Buhari gives reason for silence on Lekki Tollgate shooting

In its statement, the High Commission said, “We remain concerned by acts of looting and violence in Nigeria and urge security services use restraint as the order is restored. Working with all stakeholders, judicial panels of inquiry must investigate all incidents, including Lekki and ensure accountability for crimes.”

What you should know

Jaiz bank ads

The Judicial Panel of Inquiry set up by the Lagos state government to handle all cases of police brutality in the state have also been mandated to conduct an inquiry into the shooting of unarmed protesters last week.

Fidelity ads

Amnesty International earlier said that 12 people were allegedly shot dead by the police and army at two locations during the hijacked protests.

Explore Data on the Nairametrics Research Website

 

Continue Reading
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
ikeja electric
Advertisement
Advertisement
Patricia
Advertisement
FCMB ads
Advertisement
IZIKJON
Advertisement
Fidelity ads
act markets
Advertisement
first bank
Advertisement
bitad
Advertisement
Stallion ads
Advertisement
financial calculator
Advertisement
deals book
Advertisement
app
Advertisement